We have some of the best cheesecake in town, and that’s because we use a secret ingredient. No, it isn’t love. It actually is a throwback to our St. Louis roots. Stop by to see why our customers are calling it the Best St. Louis Cheesecake.
We have done away with the traditional graham cracker crust and have leveled up our cheesecakes by starting with a gooey butter cake bottom and building our cheesecake from there. Talk about a creamy decadent dessert.
Get ready to spoil yourself, your loved ones, and your friends with some of our amazing gooey cakes and cheesecakes.
Best St. Louis Cheesecake
Want to know why our cheesecake have been called the Best St. Louis Cheesecake? Our cheesecakes are not your traditional cheesecake. We replace the graham cracker crust with a St. Louis classic gooey butter cake bottom to add another layer of goodness to your treats.
We know that is enough to get your mouth watering. Thats why we want to invite you to come try the best St. Louis cheesecake for yourself, and then you will know what everyone has been talking about.
Our full cheesecakes come in 1/2 sheet pans cut into approximately 4×4 squares serving 16. Bars can be cut smaller to serve more people. We just believe that once you take a bite you will not want to share.
Premium Gooey Butter Cheesecake mini (3″ individual) $3 / slice $4 / half order $28 / full order $56
- Plain Cheesecake
- Strawberry Cheesecake
- Blueberry Cheesecake
- Cherry Cheesecake
- Chocolate Cheesecake
- Raspberry Cheesecake
Signature Gooey Butter Cheesecake mini (3″ individual) $3.75 / slice $5 / half order $32 / full order $64
- Chocolate Silk Pie Cheesecake
- Turtle Cheesecake
- Banana Pudding Cheesecake
- Triple Berry Cheesecake
- Caramel Apple Pie Cheesecake
- Peach Cobbler Cheesecake
- Triple Chocolate
- Red Velvet Cheesecake
- Banana Split Cheesecake
- Berry Blast Cheesecake
- Tropical Breeze Cheesecake
- Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake
- Pumpkin Pie Bars
- Pecan Pie Cheesecake
- Peanut Butter Pie Cheesecake
- Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cheesecake
- Smore’s Cheesecake
- Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake
- Heath Cheesecake
- Pistachio Cheesecake
- Tiramisu Cheesecake
Craz Pack $16
Our Craz Packs come with a sample of 2 signature cheesecakes and 2 premium cheesecakes
Mini Craz Pack $7.50
Sample pack of some of our gooey butter cake, signature cheesecakes, and premium cheesecakes
If you are looking to cater a wedding, event, or need to order a large quantity, then contact us to learn about our bulk pricing.
St. Louis’ Favorite Gooey Butter Cake
Of course, we have amazing gooey butter cake. Our Gooey Butter Cake is so good that we were actually asked to do a show with Repertory Theatre of St. Louis.
That is correct in their holiday show in 2020, we were part of the Cooking, Carols, & Cocktails. It was such an honor to be teaching all of St. Louis how to make this delicious St. Louis classic.
Our full gooey butter cakes come in 1/2 sheet pans cut into approximately 4×4 squares serving 16. Bars can be cut smaller to serve more people, but we promise after one bite you won’t want to share.
Gooey Butter Mini (3″) $2.75 / slice $4 / half order $25 / full order $48
- Classic Gooey Butter Cake
- Lemon Coconut Gooey Butter Cake
- Carrot Cake Gooey Butter Cake
- German Chocolate Gooey Butter Cake
- Fudgy Peanut Butter Cake
- Strawberry Gooey Butter Cake
- Maple Pecan Gooey Butter Cake
- Pineapple Inside Out Gooey Butter Cake
- Fudgy Brownie Gooey Butter Cake
If you are looking to cater a wedding, event, or need to order a large quantity, then contact us to learn about our bulk pricing.
Catering Coffee 2 liter (6-8 cups) $14.50 2 1/2 gallon (30-40 cups) $44.50
We have partnered with a local coffee shop to provide our customers a convenient way to provide coffee for events. All coffee orders include cups, creamer, and sugar packets.
FAQ
Can I only order from one menu?
No, this menu just has our pie, but we offer several different dessert options. Take a look at our dessert and pie menu. If you are looking for something specific, then send us an email at ordering@perfectlypastry.com or chat with us below. Click the “Let’s Chat!” box to discuss your ideas.
Do you have a storefront?
Yes, we do have a retail space. You may pick your order up at 201 N Main St., Waterloo, IL 62298. We are open Tuesday- Saturday from 730am -2pm.
Can I request a customized order?
We never want to say no to a challenge, but there are times when we cannot accommodate your requests. We are so sorry about that. However, reach out to us and let us know what you want. Then we will look at our schedule, products, and recipes to see if we can accommodate your requests. Please email all special requests to ordering@perfectlypastry.com.
How far in advance do I need to place an order?
All customer orders must be placed 7 days in advance. Orders will not be started until payment is received. If payment is not received 7 days prior to the pick up/delivery date, then the order will be canceled. You will receive a cancellation email. If you need the items sooner than 7 days, please contact us ordering@perfectlypastry.com, 636-422-3299, or chat option. We will do what we can to work with you to get the order scheduled.
How do I order?
Great question!!! We are so excited you decided to use us for your next event. Ordering is simple. Email us at ordering@perfectlypastry.com, hit us up on social, chat in the box, or give us a call at 636-422-3299
Do you do catering for weddings, corporate events, or venue events?
Yes, we cater any event. We require a 35% deposit to hold the date. Final payment is required 7 days in advance of pick up or deliver. If the final payment is not received within 7 days of the scheduled pick up/delivery, you will receive an email letting you know your order will be cancelled.
Catering orders can be cancelled prior to the week before pick up/delivery, but the deposit will not be returned. No refunds for cancellations within the 7 days of pick up/delivery for all catering orders.
Do you need a decorated cake for your event?
If so, have you thought about trying our delicious cupcakes instead? Our cupcakes are more than enough to replace a silly cake, but if you are adamant about a cake, then you will have to go elsewhere. Unfortunately, we do not bake cakes at this time. We are looking to expand our services and are working hard to get a chef trained for cake services. Keep checking back for updates on our progress.
Do you do weddings?
Weddings. Oh, the big wedding question. We currently will do cupcakes, cheesecakes, gooey butter cakes, cookie cakes, and pies for weddings. We also prepare breakfast catering for the morning of the wedding. So many brides forget that they need to plan to feed the bridal party on the BIG Day before the wedding starts. Contact us directly to schedule a consultation to discuss all the details for your big day. Email us ordering@perfectlypastry.com or chat with us by clicking on the “Let’s Chat!” box.